Pulumi Explained: Purpose, Business Benefits, Limitations, and IaC Alternatives

Pulumi is a modern Infrastructure as Code (IaC) tool that enables you to provision and manage cloud infrastructure using general-purpose programming languages like:

• Python
• TypeScript / JavaScript
• Go
• C# / F# / .NET

Instead of using YAML (CloudFormation), JSON, or HCL (Terraform), you write infrastructure in real code — making it powerful and flexible.

Pulumi – Purpose

Objective	Description
Infrastructure as Code	Automate cloud infrastructure provisioning
Dev-First IaC	Use programming logic (if-else, loops, modules)
Multi-Cloud Support	Supports AWS, Azure, GCP, Kubernetes, etc.
Secrets Management	Built-in secret encryption and config
Testable Infra	Write unit/integration tests for infra code

---

Business Use Cases

Use Case	Description
DevOps Automation	Automate provisioning of VMs, networks, databases
Multi-Cloud Deployments	Same codebase for AWS, Azure, GCP
Developer Portals	Platform teams use Pulumi for self-service infrastructure
Modern App Infrastructure	EKS, serverless (Lambda), S3, API Gateway, RDS, etc.
Enterprise Policy Enforcement	Integrate with OPA, RBAC, and secret backends
Dynamic Infra-as-Code	Use functions, classes, and libraries to reuse logic

---

When to Use Pulumi

Criteria	Pulumi is Ideal When…
You want to use real code (Python, TS, Go) for infra logic
You want strong abstraction, modules, and reuse
You need multi-cloud support from one tool
You need to integrate tightly with CI/CD pipelines
Your dev team prefers programming languages over YAML/DSL
You’re building a developer platform or IDP

---

Pulumi Disadvantages

Limitation	Description
Steeper learning curve	Requires software development skills (Python, TS)
Less declarative than Terraform	Not as easy to read or diff for large teams
Vendor lock-in (Pulumi Cloud)	Uses a managed backend by default (can be self-hosted though)
Smaller community	Compared to Terraform or CloudFormation
Tooling maturity	Some third-party integrations not as widely supported

---

Pulumi vs Other IaC Tools (Comparison Table)

Feature / Tool	Pulumi	Terraform	AWS CDK	CloudFormation
Language Support	Python, TS, Go, .NET	HCL	Python, TS, Java, C#	YAML / JSON
Multi-Cloud Support	Yes	Yes	AWS only	AWS only
Modularity & Reuse	High (OOP, loops)	Limited (modules only)	High	YAML reuse is hard
Declarative Style	Imperative	Declarative	Imperative	Declarative
Tooling Ecosystem	Growing	Mature	AWS-focused	Native AWS
Testing Support	Built-in (unit/integration)	With third-party tools	With Jest, etc.	Hard to test
Secrets Handling	Built-in	With Vault, etc.	With SecretsManager	With SecretsManager
Learning Curve	Steep if not dev	Lower (YAML-style DSL)	Medium (OOP + AWS SDK)	Beginner-friendly
State Management	Cloud/local state	Remote/local backends	via CDK	via StackSets

---

Summary

When to Use Pulumi	When to Use Terraform / CDK
✅ If your team prefers Python/TS/Go	✅ If you prefer HCL/YAML style
✅ If you need multi-cloud automation	✅ If you’re AWS-only (CDK or CloudFormation)
✅ If you want to reuse complex logic	✅ If your infra is mostly declarative
✅ For modern developer portals/IDPs	✅ For large teams with low-code experience

Install Pulumi & AWS SDK for Python

# Install Pulumi CLI
curl -fsSL https://get.pulumi.com | sh

# Install AWS CLI and configure your credentials
aws configure

# Create a virtual environment (optional but recommended)
python3 -m venv venv
source venv/bin/activate

# Install Pulumi AWS SDK
pip install pulumi pulumi_aws

Step-by-Step: Secure EC2 Creation with Configurable Environment

Step : Set Configuration (No Hardcoded Secrets or AMI)

# Set values securely
pulumi config set aws:region us-east-1
pulumi config set --secret ec2AppSecretKey "super-secret-key"
pulumi config set ec2InstanceType "t2.micro"
pulumi config set ec2AmiId "ami-0c94855ba95c71c99"  # Amazon Linux 2 AMI for us-east-1

Step : Pulumi __main__.py (Clean, Configurable, Secure)

import pulumi
import pulumi_aws as aws

# Load configurations
config = pulumi.Config()
region = config.require("aws:region")
ami_id = config.require("ec2AmiId")
instance_type = config.require("ec2InstanceType")
app_secret_key = config.require_secret("ec2AppSecretKey")  # Stored securely

# Render user data script using the secret
user_data_script = app_secret_key.apply(lambda secret: f"""#!/bin/bash
echo 'export APP_SECRET_KEY="{secret}"' >> /etc/profile
""")

# Create a minimal security group
sec_group = aws.ec2.SecurityGroup("ssh-sec-group",
    description="Allow SSH access",
    ingress=[{
        "protocol": "tcp",
        "from_port": 22,
        "to_port": 22,
        "cidr_blocks": ["0.0.0.0/0"],
    }],
    egress=[{
        "protocol": "-1",
        "from_port": 0,
        "to_port": 0,
        "cidr_blocks": ["0.0.0.0/0"],
    }]
)

# Create EC2 instance with clean config references
instance = aws.ec2.Instance("pulumi-ec2-instance",
    instance_type=instance_type,
    ami=ami_id,
    vpc_security_group_ids=[sec_group.id],
    associate_public_ip_address=True,
    user_data=user_data_script,
    tags={"Name": "PulumiSecureInstance"}
)

# Export public IP
pulumi.export("instance_id", instance.id)
pulumi.export("instance_public_ip", instance.public_ip)

Pulumi Command Cheat Sheet

Command	Description
pulumi new [template]	Create a new Pulumi project (e.g., pulumi new aws-python)
pulumi login	Authenticate to Pulumi service or local backend
pulumi stack init <name>	Create a new stack/environment (e.g., dev, staging)
pulumi config set <key> <value>	Set configuration values for stack
pulumi up	Preview and deploy infrastructure changes
pulumi preview	Show what will change without applying
pulumi destroy	Tear down all resources in the stack
pulumi stack	Show current stack information
pulumi config	View current stack configuration
pulumi refresh	Refresh the state of your stack
pulumi stack select <name>	Switch between stacks (environments)
pulumi state delete <urn>	Manually delete a resource from state
pulumi import	Import existing resources into Pulumi state
pulumi logout	Sign out from Pulumi service/backend